Skip to content
Log inStart free

Exchange Value Calculation

In an exchange, the value of the items a customer returns is compared with the value of the replacements. If the replacements cost more, the customer pays the difference; if they cost less, the difference goes back to the customer.

Updated
Reading time
3 min
On this page

When a customer exchanges items, the value of what they send back rarely matches the value of the replacements exactly. An exchange settles that gap by comparing the two: the total value of the returned items against the total value of the replacement products you add. This article explains how that comparison works so you know whether the customer owes more or is owed a difference. The exchange itself is set up in Exchange.

How the comparison works

Situation What happens
Replacements cost more than the returned items The customer pays the difference
Replacements cost less than the returned items The difference goes back to the customer
Replacements equal the returned items An even exchange, with nothing owed either way

Before you begin

  • You are setting up an exchange on a return, with returned items selected and replacements added.
  • Open Orders > Overview in the admin sidebar, open a fulfilled order and select Return, then add exchange items to see the value comparison.

Steps

1. Total the value of the returned items

Start from the value of what the customer is sending back. The returned item keeps its order price, so the returned side is the sum of the selected items at those prices.

2. Total the value of the replacements

Add the value of the replacement products. Each replacement uses its own product price when you add it in the Exchange items section, so the replacement side is the sum of those prices.

3. Compare the two totals

The difference between the two totals is what settles. Using a returned item priced at $299 as an example:

Returned item Replacement Difference
$299 A $315 item The customer pays $16 more
$299 A $99 item $200 goes back to the customer
$299 A $299 item Even exchange, nothing owed

Because the two totals drive the difference, check both sides before you create the exchange so the settlement is what you and the customer expect.

Best practices

  • Compare both totals. Look at the value of the returned items and the value of the replacements together, since the difference is what settles.
  • Tell the customer about a difference. If replacements cost more or less, let the customer know what they owe or get back before you create the exchange.
  • Keep it simple where you can. An even or near-even exchange is the easiest for everyone, so suggest a similar-priced replacement when it fits.

If something goes wrong

  • The difference is not what you expected. Recheck the returned items and the replacement products, since the totals of both sides drive the difference.
  • You need a refund instead. If the customer should get money back rather than replacements, use a refund instead of an exchange, following Issue a Refund.

Next steps

Still stuck?

More in Returns

  • Return and Refund Policy

    The Return and refund policy editor is where you write the policy that tells customers how returns and refunds work. You can start from a template, generate it, or write your own, from Settings, Policies.

  • The Return Process

    An overview of how a return works end to end, from a customer request through inspecting the item and resolving it with a refund or exchange, and where each part is managed in your store.

  • Restock a Return

    When you process a return, you can restock the returned items back into inventory at a chosen location, review the refund due, and choose whether to issue the refund now or later.

  • Select Items to Return

    The section on the Create return page where you choose what is coming back: how the quantity is capped at what was fulfilled, the reason that appears once you pick one, and the summary lines your choice produces, including tax.

All 15 articles in Returns

We use cookies

Necessary cookies keep the site working. With your permission we also use analytics and marketing cookies. Change your choice any time in Cookie settings.